Skip to content

A new independent economic analysis has found that the promise of economic prosperity from deep-sea mining does not stand up to scrutiny, with the proposed industry likely to destroy economic value and cost governments more than it generates in public revenue. 

Case Not Proven: The Economics of Deep-Sea Mining, produced by Koinon Consulting and commissioned by the Deep Sea Conservation Coalition (DSCC), Oceans North, the International Union for the Conservation of Nature (IUCN), Oceano Azul Foundation, and Dona Bertarelli Philanthropy, stress-tests the industry’s own economic projections against the risks associated with major frontier resource projects. 

Using data and economic projections submitted by The Metals Company’s (TMC) NORI-D and TOML projects, the analysis finds that in more than eight out of ten realistic scenarios, deep-sea mining destroys value – even before accounting for environmental and other social costs -, with a 61% chance that investors never get their money back. While TMC’s projections suggest deep-sea mining could generate billions in value, the stress-test produces a median outcome of a -$5 billion loss.

“Deep-sea mining doesn’t stand up as an attractive investment. The returns are too low for the technical, operational, environmental, price, demand and social risks involved,” said Johnny West, report author and Principal at Koinon Consulting. “What my analysis shows is that the industry’s underlying business model does not hold up when its own projections are tested against realistic risks.” 

“The deep-sea mining industry has spent years promising governments that it will deliver economic prosperity. This independent analysis shows those promises do not hold up,” said Sofia Tsenikli, DSCC Global Campaign Director. “Deep-sea mining loses money in most realistic scenarios, even before the costs of environmental damage are considered. It’s bad business and bad for the planet. A moratorium is the economically responsible choice.”  

The economic risks extend beyond the companies seeking to mine the seabed. The report finds that deep-sea mining could leave governments worse off by reducing revenues from existing terrestrial mining. These losses would fall primarily on countries that depend on terrestrial mineral production, notably Indonesia, South Africa, the Democratic Republic of the Congo and Gabon, among others. 

Sponsoring states would also take on significant legal and environmental risks, while receiving little financial benefit. In most scenarios, sponsoring States receive no corporate income tax from deep-sea mining projects.

The analysis does not account for the potentially significant costs of environmental damage or wider impacts on fisheries, livelihoods and ocean ecosystems, likely further increasing the economic costs of deep-sea mining. With deep-sea mining failing to demonstrate a clear public benefit even before those costs are considered, the findings reinforce the case for governments to support a moratorium on deep-sea mining.

This study confirms that deep-sea mining remains economically unattractive from a commercial investment perspective, with the risks of cost overruns making an already weak business case even less compelling,” said Torsten Thiele, Founder, Global Ocean Trust and IUCN WCPA Sustainable Finance Specialist Group. “The findings also highlight that the risks extend beyond mining companies to sponsoring States and countries dependent on terrestrial mining. This evidence should be fully considered by ISA Members when making decisions on behalf of humankind as a whole.

“This report shows that there is nothing to gain from deep seabed mining. Not only would it be environmentally devastating, but it would cause financial losses for many countries and communities,” said Nicole Zanesco, International Policy Advisor, Oceans North. “Canada is one of the countries set to lose revenue each year if deep seabed mining goes ahead. Saying no to deep seabed mining is the best business decision Canada can make. Save money, save the ocean, and save something for future generations.”

“This independent report confirms what many experts and scholars have long suspected and cautioned: the narrative spread by proponents on the promised economic benefits of deep-sea mining is a myth. Far from being an economic necessity, deep-sea mining is essentially a gamble where humankind stands to lose a lot more than any speculative gains. This report confirms that the only responsible pathway is to now press pause on deep-sea mining and to turn our attention to protection and truly valuing our natural capital,” Pradeep Singh, Ocean Governance Expert at Oceano Azul Foundation.

“What distinguishes this report is its method: rather than constructing an independent model, it stress-tests the proponent’s own figures and still finds the financial case does not hold. That conclusion is consistent with what rigorous economic analysis across different methodologies and scales has been finding. Piece by piece, the picture is becoming harder to ignore. On its own economic merits, the case for deep-sea mining does not stand,” said Raphaëlle Flint, Senior Program Manager, Dona Bertarelli Philanthropy. 

ENDS

Contact

For further information or expert interviews, please contact: agata@communicationsinc.co.uk. 

Notes to Editor: 

  • Under international law, the ISA has obligations to compensate developing countries that are seriously affected by deep-sea mining. The analysis finds that losses to governments taxing land-based mining could exceed revenues generated for the ISA, meaning the ISA would be unable to compensate affected governments at anything close to parity while retaining income for benefit-sharing.
  • The analysis draws on data submitted by The Metals Company for its NORI-D and TOML projects and stress-tests the industry’s projections against risks including cost overruns, production shortfalls and changes in metal prices.
  • The analysis does not attempt to quantify the full economic costs of environmental damage or wider impacts on fisheries, livelihoods and ocean ecosystems. The report notes that these costs are difficult to quantify given gaps in scientific knowledge, and that the economic impacts on livelihoods and wider economic activity have not been modelled.
  • The Deep Sea Conservation Coalition (DSCC) is an alliance of more than 135 organizations
  • worldwide advocating for the protection of the deep sea.

 

Key Findings: 

  • Deep-sea mining loses money: TMC projects around $23 billion in value from deep-sea mining, but stress-testing those projections produces a median outcome of a -$5 billion loss. In more than 8 out of 10 (83%) realistic scenarios, deep-sea mining destroys economic value, and there is a 61% chance investors never get their money back. 
  • The public loses more than it gains: At all levels of production tested, the losses to governments from terrestrial mining exceed the revenues generated by the ISA. At peak production, governments taxing land-based mining could lose between  $1.1 – 1.19 billion a year, while the ISA would collect between  $ 0.55 – 1.1 billion due to the fact that seabed supply of minerals would depress global metal prices. Developing countries bear significant costs: Indonesia could lose approximately $460 million a year in government mining revenue, South Africa $270 million, the Democratic Republic of the Congo $250 million and Gabon $110 million.
  • Sponsoring States carry the risk: In 48% of scenarios, sponsoring States receive no corporate income tax from deep-sea mining projects, despite carrying legal and environmental responsibilities.
  • Environmental costs are not included: The analysis does not account for the economic costs of environmental damage or wider impacts on fisheries, livelihoods and ocean ecosystems.